Montauk Yacht Club Hotel, Montauk - Reviews, Rooms Options & Prices 2025

Book with us

Up to 10% cheaper

than on Booking.com

Key details

About the Resort

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

Montauk Yacht Club is an award-winning Hamptons hotel ideal for weekend getaways, family vacations, and milestone events. Its nautical-inspired décor and stunning waterfront views offer a blend of bygone elegance and modern comfort. The resort's 106 guest rooms, villas, and suites feature private balconies or terraces, making it a prime destination for travelers seeking luxury and relaxation in a picturesque coastal setting.

Location

Situated in Montauk, the resort is close to several state parks and notable landmarks, providing easy access to natural beauty and outdoor activities. Long Island MacArthur Airport is approximately 115 km away, ensuring convenient travel options for guests.

Rooms

The resort features a variety of guest rooms, villas, and suites designed to provide comfort and stunning views. Many accommodations boast private balconies or terraces overlooking the waterfront or tranquil courtyard, enhancing the overall guest experience.

Eat & Drink

Montauk Yacht Club offers a range of dining options that capture the essence of local cuisine. Guests can indulge in signature dishes that highlight fresh, seasonal ingredients, ensuring a memorable culinary experience throughout their stay.

Leisure & Business

With access to pristine beaches, the resort provides numerous recreational activities such as world-class saltwater fishing and water sports. Onsite facilities include a pool, providing guests the perfect space to unwind and enjoy leisure time.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Guest Room

Max:

4 persons

33 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Balcony

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Villa

Max:

3 persons

33 m²

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

Heating

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Deluxe Room

Max:

2 persons

33 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Sea view

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

Explore available ways to reach your dream destination

City Center

Montauk 2.5 mi

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 69.7 mi

Tweed-New Haven (HVN) 107.4 mi

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Dreamy Accommodations

“The spacious room featured a walk-in closet and a lovely balcony that added a touch of luxury to our stay.” view full review

Relaxing Retreat

“The tranquil pool area offered a serene water view, making it the perfect spot to unwind and soak up the sun.” view full review

Great Dining Options

“The diverse dining experiences within the resort provided delicious meals that enhanced our overall enjoyment.” view full review

Well-Designed Spaces

“The various recreational facilities were well-maintained, creating a fun environment to relax and play.” view full review

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi in public areas
Paid parking
Safe deposit box
24-hour reception
Pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
24-hour security
Baggage storage
Private beach
Allergy-free rooms
ATM/Cash machine
Coffee shop
Fireplace
Smoke detectors
Electric vehicle charging station
Fire extinguishers
Key card access
Key access

Sports & Fitness

Fitness center
Water sports
Hiking
Cycling
Tennis court
Golf course
Fishing

Services

Pet amenities available
Room service
Housekeeping
Laundry
Dry cleaning
Welcome drink

Dining

Restaurant
Snack bar
Bar/ Lounge area
Special diet menus

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Children

Children's pool

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Seasonal indoor pool
Beach access
Spa & wellness center

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Mini-bar
Sitting area
Patio
Terrace
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Bathtub
Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

Map view

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

City landmarks

50 S Fairview Ave

Montauk Downs State Park

1.4 mi

W Lake Dr

Gosman's Dock

1.3 mi

Golf Course

Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course

1.4 mi

Parks

Shadmoor State Park

2.1 mi

Farm

Rita's Stable

1.7 mi

Farm

Deep Hollow Ranch

2.1 mi

67 South Essex Street

Saint Therese of Lisieux Church

2.3 mi

18 Ditch Plains Rd

Ditch Plains Beach

2.2 mi

Parks

Fort Pond Bay Park

2.5 mi

Museums

Second House Museum

2.8 mi

Parks

Camp Hero State Park

2.5 mi

Store

Sunset Surf Shack

2.5 mi

Parks

Kirk Park Beach

2.8 mi

Montauk

Lake Montauk

2.8 mi

Fort Pond Bay

2.7 mi

1898 Montauk Hwy

Camp Hero

3.0 mi

Lighthouse

Montauk Point Lighthouse

4.0 mi

Nearby

Marina

Star Island Yacht Club and Marina

1200 ft

Restaurants

Star Island Grill

400 ft

Star Island Rd

Westlake Fish House

2700 ft

352 W Lake Dr

Swallow East Restaurant

1.2 mi

474 W Lake Dr

Grey Lady

4900 ft

440 W Lake Dr

Tiny Harbor Asian Cafe

4900 ft

440 W Lake Dr Unit B

The Dock

1.1 mi

482 West Lake Dr

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience

70%

liked the resort and would come back again

7.0/10

Very good

Rooms

7.8

Location

8.3

Service

7.8

Dining

6.3

3.5/5 based on 80 reviews

#25 of 39 hotels in Montauk based on Tripadvisor

Thomas

United States of America, December 2024

9.0/10

I had an amazing time at Star Island Resort! The serene views and upscale amenities really made my stay special. The rooms were beautifully appointed and spacious, offering a lovely retreat after a day of activities. However, I was hoping for a bit more variety in the dining options, particularly for breakfast. Overall, it's a fantastic spot for a getaway, especially with family due to the kid-friendly activities.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms were spacious and beautifully decorated, with a lovely view of the marina.

Service

10.0

Service was top-notch, especially at the beach and pool areas where the staff consistently checked in and catered to our needs.

Location

10.0

The location is beautiful, right by the marina, and the beach is private and peaceful.

Dining

7.0

Showfish offered some great dining options, but I would have liked to see more variety for breakfast.

Facilities

9.0

The facilities were excellent with multiple pools and fun beach activities, perfect for a relaxing day.

Dana

United States of America, October 2024

5.4/10

Rooms

Service

Location

Dining

Facilities

Daniel

United States of America, September 2024

6.4/10

While this hotel has a charming and traditional feel, I found the recent renovations left a lot to be desired. The property itself has a great atmosphere and an ideal location, but the new design choices made it feel confusing and overcrowded at times. Although the staff provided decent service, I cannot overlook the shortcomings in the dining options and overall layout. It's a mixed bag, leaning more towards the disappointing side.

Rooms

7.0

Our room was very spacious with two double beds, but those beds were on the smaller side which made it a bit cozy for two people. It was clean but the view left something to be desired since we overlooked the parking lot.

Service

6.0

Service was hit or miss, with some staff being quite pleasant, while others seemed to be uninterested. It was frustrating when our requests were not met, especially regarding dining and check-in issues.

Location

8.0

The hotel's location is a standout, providing easy access to beautiful scenery and a relaxing setting. However, the layout, particularly around dining and lounging spaces, felt crowded which detracted from the overall experience.

Dining

5.0

Dining options were lacking in quality and variety. The prices seemed high for what was often a mediocre experience, and the redesign of the dining areas made it feel cramped.

Facilities

6.0

The facilities were updated but not always welcoming. The changes made some spaces feel more claustrophobic than inviting, which was disappointing considering the potential of the areas.

Robert

United States of America, August 2024

8.4/10

My stay at Gurney's Star Island was a delightful experience filled with tranquility and upscale amenities. The rooms were mostly lovely, although not extensively updated, and the dining options were creative and tasteful, although I found the portion sizes slightly lacking. The service was attentive and personalized, contributing to a serene atmosphere perfect for relaxation. However, I encountered some noise issues during my stay, which detracted from the otherwise peaceful environment.

Rooms

8.0

The guest bedrooms were lovely and pleasant, though some areas appear a bit untouched by recent renovations. They offered comfort and a good night's sleep, with views overlooking Lake Montauk.

Service

9.0

The staff were accommodating and attentive. Despite some noise disturbances from fellow guests, the response from management was prompt and effective.

Location

8.0

Located in a serene area away from the noisy oceanfront, it provided a calm retreat. Its proximity to Gurney's Oceanfront Resort gives guests a chance to enjoy lively beach activities as well.

Dining

8.0

Showfish offered a fantastic dining experience with creative dishes, although the portion sizes were on the smaller side for the price. Overall, the quality of the food was impressive.

Facilities

9.0

The facilities included multiple pools and a lovely beach area, making it a nice spot to unwind. The poolside bar was a great addition for relaxation after a busy day.

Frank

United States of America, August 2024

6.2/10

We had a mixed experience at Gurney's Star Island. The rooms were beautifully decorated and comfortable, but the noise levels from neighboring guests were quite disruptive to our sleep. The dining experience was a letdown with some service hiccups, and the beach access was a nice perk. Overall, it’s a stylish place, but the noise and inconsistent dining service keep it from being a top choice.

Rooms

7.0

The rooms were stylishly renovated and quite comfortable, but the thin walls ruined the relaxing atmosphere.

Service

6.0

Service at the restaurant was a bit disorganized, affecting our dining experience overall.

Location

7.0

The hotel is nicely located with beach access, but confusing signage between properties led to initial frustration.

Dining

5.0

Dining at Showfish had some initial service issues, but the food was well-prepared when it finally arrived.